Treats - The good,
the bad and the ugly!
Those who have read other pages on this website know
that there's a bit of a campaign going on here for a common sense
approach to pet treats.
Firstly, let's ask the basic question 'Are special
treats necessary?' and the answer has to be 'No!'
We give treats for two reasons: 1) To reward behaviour,
or to encourage training, and 2) Because we want to pamper our pets
Nothing wrong with that, but do we have to buy specially
manufactured treats in order to achieve these ends?
Reasons against buying special pet treats
1) Cost:
Let's take as an example the more natural treat such
as James Wellbeloved Crackerjacks - this is not a criticism of JW,
as they are just typical of the better quality treats available
from pet shops
|
Crackerjacks from James Wellbeloved
Ingredients:
Rice, Turkey, Turkey Fat, Tomato, Potato, Potato Protein,
Poultry Protein, Mixed Herbs.
Typical Analysis:
Moisture <10%, Protein 15%, Oils and Fats 15%, Fibre 4%,
Ash 4%
Conclusions:
Effectively what we have is a protein and fat content close
to an adult dog food - a light diet - with a few herbs thrown
in which is then extruded into shapes.
Nothing expensive here!
|
Cost of 225g bag
Around £2.24 (or £9.74/kg)
If this was sold as an adult dog food it would
therefore cost
£146
for a 15kg sack!
whereas a 15kg of JW adult food normally costs
somewhere between £35 - 42 at Pets
at Home (check
current offers)
|
2) Ingredients:
This is where the fun begins - where do I start?!
Let's call James Wellbeloved treats good quality (but
expensive!) which is a fair assessment of this type of treat - good
ingredients, well packaged but costly. Now let's look at soem of
the other treats available and particularly at the ingredients that
you are paying for.
Bakers Allsorts
Ingredients:
Cereals, Meat and Animal Derivatives, Vegetable Protein Extracts,
Various Sugars, Oils and Fats, Minerals, Derivatives of Vegetable
Origin. Contains EC permitted Colourants, Antioxidants and
Preservatives.
Typical Analysis:
Moisture 24%, Protein 26%, Oils and Fats 5.5%, Fibre 1%,
Ash 6%.
Similar ingredients to a cheap dog food - but this contains
sugars, meats and cereals of unknown origin and colours and
preservatives
|
Cost of 140g bag
£1.46 (or £10.43/ kg)
This is actually more expensive per kilo than the higher
quality James Wellbeloved product!
If this was sold as an adult dog food it
would therefore cost
£156
for a 15kg sack
|
Pedigree Schmackos 20
Strip Variety Pack Treats for Dogs
Ingredients:
Meat and Animal Derivatives (Min. 4% Fresh Meat, Min. 4%
Chicken, Min. 4% Lamb, Min. 4% Rabbit, Min. 4% Turkey), Derivatives
Of Vegetable Origin, Various Sugars, Minerals, Oils and Fats.
Typical Analysis:
Moisture 17.5%, Protein 26%, Oils and Fats 10%, Fibre 12%,
Ash 4%
Mainly derivatives and with added sugars |
Cost per pack £1.95 (or £11.47/ kg)
If this was sold as an adult dog food it
would therefore cost
£172
for a 15kg sack
|
3) Excess nutrients
A lot of pet owners forget that the treats they feed
are full of fat and protein which adds to the overall nutrition
of their pet. As most pet owners already overfeed their pets (and
that probably means you!) because they don't measure out the food
according to the recommended feeding rates, then additional nutrition
as a treat simply adds to the load.
Lots of dogs and cats in the UK are overweight, or
suffer from teeth or gum problems - treats full of sugar and unnecessary
nutrients are not helping the situation!
And here I rest my case!
And offer an alternative approach to treats
So what's the alternative?
Two simple alternatives
1) Raw vegetables - Most dogs love pieces of raw carrot,
or pieces of brocolli and cauliflower stalk - crunchy, moist and
naturally sweet. Try them, they're far more healthy than any treat
on the pet shop shelf!
2) Free samples - I hope that you can see that most
treats are made from the same ingredients as the food you normally
feed - therefore why not simply ask for free samples of a food in
a different flavour (say a fish variety) and use the kibble as a
treat. Your dog is NOT going to look at you and call you a skinflint,
believe me!
Most pet food companies offer free samples, and your
pet shop certainly should - make use of this facility and stop paying
through the nose for pet treats!
Good Prices on Treats
|
|